320 vs 328, which one to choose?

[MrJosep]

Hello!

I’m about to join the family, but I have some questions first.

I’m looking at CPO F30s (2016) to replace my current commuter car. I drive 20-25,000 miles a year, mostly commuting through secondary roads (the kind with 55mph speed limit). I’m looking for a reliable, no problems, lasting engine. And my questions are:

- which trim will be best for me? 320i or 328i?
I test-drove a 328i and it was pure joy in backroads. But the dealer had no 320i for me to drive.

- is xDrive worth it?
We hardly get two days of snow a year. Sure, we get some good amount of rain sometimes, but I’ve been fine with my current non-BMW.

Thank you in advance.

[The Beastmaster]

Get the 328i since you enjoyed it so much. The 320i is the same car, but the motor is detuned by about 60 hp.

[White94RX]

Don't bother with the xdrive unless you get heavy snow.

[floydr]

You're missing the 328d (diesel). The engine lasts forever, mileage (a serious consideration for you, it would seem) is much higher - at least 10 mpg. The trim level of the 328d is the same as the 328i - both a bit higher than the 320i.

[MrJosep]

You're missing the 328d (diesel). The engine lasts forever, mileage (a serious consideration for you, it would seem) is much higher - at least 10 mpg. The trim level of the 328d is the same as the 328i - both a bit higher than the 320i.

I did look at 328d CPO’s as my first option, but there are only a handful, and at least are 50% more expensive than a similarly equipped 328i.