Hand Held Scan tool versus PC software

[SBFree]

I am in the market for a new OBD reader. I had been using software (Autoenginutiy Scantool https://www.autoenginuity.com/products/scantool/) and my laptop. Upgrading doesn't seem like the way to go. I wonder if there are reasons that others would share about hand held / stand alone devices ( like ECS Tuning's Professional BMW/MINI Scan Tool https://www.ecstuning.com/b-schwaben...020sch01a~scf/ ) verus other PC software scanners.


My use is DIY and I need to be able to perform battery registration with whatever I settle on.
Thanks in advance -
Scott

[David Mc]

Interesting question - I am a long time user of PC based software, but now use Carly (BMW/VAG/Mercedes/Porsche), primarily due to portability and the convenience of having automatic updates without having to chase up software. I am also in the process of evaluating a new hand-held tool released by Carsoft (MI6), which can be updated via the internet and is available in configurations for BMW/Mini, all European marques or worldwide. The screen on this tool is relatively large, bright and in colour - it is a whole generation further away from Carsoft's original PC based products and so far, looks easy to use. I will keep you posted when I have tested the product more thoroughly.

[Driiven]

X431 and done

[legoman67]

one reason a lot of people on here use PC based software is because you can get dealer-factory level abilities in both diagnostic and coding/programming for VERY cheap.

Handheld units that even come close to the ability the free PC software that is floating around is capable of will run you $10,000+(autologic is one that i use and am familiar with). Of course if you dont need the full suite of coding and programming options your costs go down considerably and you can pick up one that will work with your phone for around $30-100(many require you to purchase the BMW software on top of the dongle cost in order to have full access), or a self contained unit for around $1000-$2000.

It really comes down to what features you need, and the environment you are using it in.

If your just a DIY'er in your garage, and only looking to read and clear codes then a phone dongle is likely your best bet. If your an advanced DIYer and also want to experiment with coding and programming then the multitude of programs floating around these forums along with a $15 USB cable is likely what you will want(there is considerable more time investment in the setup and learning curve with the PC software compared to a phone application).

If you are a professional and are operating a general repair shop the $1000-$2000 self contained units will likely suffice. If you are a specialist in BMW or any specific manufacturer then you will likely want more then the basics and should look at units such as the autologic.