E90 thoughts sought

[Automaticftp]

All -

First post in the E9x forums. I've had lots of experience with E36 and E46 models, but it might be time to move to a E90.

I had a 03 330xi, and went through a head-on collision with a Dodge Challenger that was trying to make a left turn in front of me. My car was destroyed, but my son and I were able to open the doors and step out with nothing more than bumps and bruises.

So I'm interested in whether an E90 would be safer in a collision overall than an E46 or X3. My initial impression, based on some preliminary research, is yes, because it incorporates newer technology and materials, as well as being larger than the E46.

So I'd be grateful for opinions. Whatever I get will be a DD, and I do a fair bit of driving - work is about 26 miles one way, and I do a lot of running around with my son (and wife and daughter). I've read through some threads here and elsewhere, so please clue me in in advance on things I may have missed.

Thanks in advance!

[d21spike]

Haven't been in an accident in either so I can't comment but strictly numbers:

Safety: http://www.kbb.com/compare-cars/safety/2005-bmw-3-series-96-vs-2006-bmw-3-series-32/
Economy and Size: http://www.kbb.com/compare-cars/specs/2005-bmw-3-series-96-vs-2006-bmw-3-series-32/

For the sake of comparison I selected both 325i sedans in RWD. Just based off of that, the E90 edges ahead. BMW's have always been known to be "safe" vehicles and at least according this data the E90 marginally takes the win. Looking at economy and size. EPA ratings for the E90 are slightly higher (this will change with the other models) and appears to accommodate slightly more room.

Technical details aside, take into account the ownership perspective. This will be my opinion and by no means is it 100% true for all owners. If you're looking for a more modern feel, the E90 wins. If you plan on doing the work yourself on the vehicle, the level of difficulty is similar with the exception of a few things like the waterpump/thermostat where the E90 is more difficult. Then consider the increased presence of electronics and automated control in the E90, this too can raise upkeep cost. On the flip side of the coin, E46's are older so lower mileage vehicles will be more difficult to find as well as potential being more worn down due to the age. Cost of parts, for the most part should be similar in general maintenance but once you get to more complicated items the E90 will cost more, at least until it ages more. Each chassis will have it's typical gremlins, presently I own one of each but thus far my E90 335i with less miles has needed more work than my E46 325i (this is partially due to the nature of the 335i).

Summary

E90: PRO higher safety ratings
PRO more room
PRO better economy (subjective)
PRO more power
PRO more modern feel
PRO easier to find a lower mileage model
CON potentially higher maintenance costs
CON potentially more labor intensive
CON potentially higher purchase price
CON more complex electronics to fail

E46: PRO most maintenance costs can be reasonable
PRO potentially cheaper initial purchase cost
PRO potentially easier to troubleshoot/diagnose
CON early models experience rear subframe issues
CON more difficult to find lower mileage
CON potentially more wear and tear
CON lack of more modern features

In the end get whichever is more pleasing and better suits your budget, both are great vehicles. Myself personally I'd lean towards something newer.

[Automaticftp]

dspike21 -

THANK YOU for a wonderfully informative and helpful response! I appreciate it.

I'll try a couple different cars, and would plan on doing as much as possible myself.

Thanks again - I think you covered just about everything.

[d21spike]

dspike21 -

THANK YOU for a wonderfully informative and helpful response! I appreciate it.

I'll try a couple different cars, and would plan on doing as much as possible myself.

Thanks again - I think you covered just about everything.

No problem, just be objective and have a PPI on whichever vehicle you consider purchasing. As far as maintenance, the forums can be a great help in terms of guides and troubleshooting. Also, Pelican Parts has quite a few how to guides.